In 1970, when a thick layer of salt was discovered beneath the deep Mediterranean seafloor, the prophetic prediction of James Hutton about the origin of salt rocks became reality. The initial hypothesis that a salinity crisis affected the Mediterranean Sea between 5 and 6 Ma ago then evolved into contrasting interpretations. However, these theories agree that the crisis was triggered by geodynamic and eustatic forcings causing the reduction of Atlantic connections at Gibraltar, as remarkably anticipated by Hutton in 1788. The scientific debate on the Messinian salinity crisis has been characterized by the opposition between catastrophic and gradualistic scenarios, renewing the geological controversies of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. The current catastrophic paradigm of the Messinian salinity crisis envisages a nearly complete Mediterranean desiccation and its almost instantaneous refilling following the collapse of the Gibraltar sill. Alternative, noncatastrophic scenarios, commonly indicated as ‘gradualist’ or ‘actualist’, are considered inadequate to explain unlikely events, such as the formation of salt giants. The analysis of the different scenarios reveals an amazing paradox. While the catastrophic paradigm is based on actualist arguments, the ‘gradualist’ scenarios imply processes and environmental settings which, albeit plausible on a physical basis, do not show presentday analogues.

James Hutton and the origin of salt rocks: implications for the catastrophic v. uniformitarian controversy in the Messinian salinity crisis debate / Roveri, M., Lugli, S., Manzi, V. - In: In the Footsteps of Hutton: a Celebration of the Tercentenary of the Birth of James Hutton / [a cura di] Harley, S. L. and Edmonds, M.. - [s.l], 2026. - pp. 1-22 [10.1144/gslspecpub2025-125]

James Hutton and the origin of salt rocks: implications for the catastrophic v. uniformitarian controversy in the Messinian salinity crisis debate

Lugli, Stefano
Writing – Review & Editing
;
2026

Abstract

In 1970, when a thick layer of salt was discovered beneath the deep Mediterranean seafloor, the prophetic prediction of James Hutton about the origin of salt rocks became reality. The initial hypothesis that a salinity crisis affected the Mediterranean Sea between 5 and 6 Ma ago then evolved into contrasting interpretations. However, these theories agree that the crisis was triggered by geodynamic and eustatic forcings causing the reduction of Atlantic connections at Gibraltar, as remarkably anticipated by Hutton in 1788. The scientific debate on the Messinian salinity crisis has been characterized by the opposition between catastrophic and gradualistic scenarios, renewing the geological controversies of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. The current catastrophic paradigm of the Messinian salinity crisis envisages a nearly complete Mediterranean desiccation and its almost instantaneous refilling following the collapse of the Gibraltar sill. Alternative, noncatastrophic scenarios, commonly indicated as ‘gradualist’ or ‘actualist’, are considered inadequate to explain unlikely events, such as the formation of salt giants. The analysis of the different scenarios reveals an amazing paradox. While the catastrophic paradigm is based on actualist arguments, the ‘gradualist’ scenarios imply processes and environmental settings which, albeit plausible on a physical basis, do not show presentday analogues.
2026
In the Footsteps of Hutton: a Celebration of the Tercentenary of the Birth of James Hutton
Harley, S. L. and Edmonds, M.
James Hutton and the origin of salt rocks: implications for the catastrophic v. uniformitarian controversy in the Messinian salinity crisis debate / Roveri, M., Lugli, S., Manzi, V. - In: In the Footsteps of Hutton: a Celebration of the Tercentenary of the Birth of James Hutton / [a cura di] Harley, S. L. and Edmonds, M.. - [s.l], 2026. - pp. 1-22 [10.1144/gslspecpub2025-125]
Roveri, Marco; Lugli, Stefano; Manzi, Vinicio
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Roveri et al_2026_James Hutton and the origin of salt rocks GSL.pdf

Accesso riservato

Tipologia: VOR - Versione pubblicata dall'editore
Dimensione 6.3 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
6.3 MB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
Pubblicazioni consigliate

Licenza Creative Commons
I metadati presenti in IRIS UNIMORE sono rilasciati con licenza Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal, mentre i file delle pubblicazioni sono rilasciati con licenza Attribuzione 4.0 Internazionale (CC BY 4.0), salvo diversa indicazione.
In caso di violazione di copyright, contattare Supporto Iris

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11380/1424969
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
  • OpenAlex 0
social impact