Unparallel resilience of shallow-water tropical calcifiers (foraminifera and scleractinian reef corals) during the early Paleogene global warming intervals

Investigating the fossil record to provide evidence about the response of shallow-water tropical calcifiers to past warming events is crucial considering that they are severely threatened by current global warming. We thus focused our attention on scleractinian reef corals (SRC) and shallow-water foraminifera (SWF), both mainly symbiont-bearing organisms, analysing and comparing their diversity patterns during the Paleocene and Eocene from datasets of the Neothetyan circum-Mediterranean region. In particular, at both genus and species level, we analysed changes in diversity, together with origination and extinction rates. Despite some biases related to biostratigraphic resolution of SRC and SWF data, our results show that they reacted differently to the major warming events of the Early Paleogene. The K/Pg mass extinction caused the disappearance of almost all SWF, whereas several corals passed this crisis and persisted up to the end of Paleocene, when the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) caused a relatively small decrease of coral diversity together with a global collapse of coral reefs. On the other hand, a rapid radiation of nummulitids and alveolinids occurred at species level. The impact of the Early Eocene Climatic Optimum (EECO) was apparently more severe for SWF than for SRC. After the Middle Eocene Climatic Optimum (MECO), the general cooling trend led to the fading of Eocene SWF genera and species, whereas SRC began their rapid diversification from Bartonian to Priabonian and culminating in the Chattian. Our results suggest that rapid warming events favoured speciation in SWF, whereas the slow cooling trend (e.g., after the MECO) favoured diversification of SRC. Our data also underline that SWF reacted differently to warming events as compared to deep-sea smaller benthic foraminifera and that the same events in the planktonic realm are not strictly coeval with those occurring in shallow-water environments. On a wider perspective, we observe that shallow-water calcifiers demonstrate a good degree of resilience to global temperature increases, even if undergoing to more or less marked reduction of biodiversity. We provide evidences for the recovery of past ecosystems from both short and long stressors.