The origin and significance of euhedral apatite crystals on conodonts

Crystal overgrowth on fossil remains is well-documented in the literature. Attention has specifically focused on bioapatite (i.e., an apatite of biochemical origin regardless of post-mortem changes) configurations, in order to decipher any possible relation to fossilization/diagenesis. This study investigates the Rare Earth Element (REE) and other High-Field-Strength Element (HFSE) composition of euhedral crystals formed on the surface of conodont elements compared with that of crystal-free surfaces. Euhedral crystals are by definition crystals characterized by sharp faces, developing solids that, for apatite, assume the form of hexagonal prisms, reflecting its crystal symmetry. Late Ordovician (Amorphognathus ordovicicus Zone) conodonts from two localities in Sardinia and the Carnic Alps (Italy) are herein investigated. Conodont elements reveal the occurrence of smooth surfaces and surfaces partially covered with euhedral crystals. Since euhedral crystals did not reasonably grow during the organism’s lifetime, the REE and HFSE analysis can provide important insights into the crystal growth process. The experimental results indicated a substantial contribution of diagenetic imprinting for all the analyzed material, although more evident on euhedral crystals that are significantly enriched in middle and, subordinately, in heavy REE with respect to smooth surfaces. The positive correlations between La + Th vs log[ΣREE] and Ce + Th vs log[ΣREE] could support the hypothesis that the neoformed euhedral crystals grew also by depleting the pristine bioapatite of the conodont elements. Nevertheless, the occurrence of two types of apatite cannot be ruled out: euhedral crystals as neoformed products of diagenetic processes and smooth surfaces as remains of the pristine conodont bioapatite after diagenesis.