EnglishA relevant question for the organization of large-scale research assessments is whether bibliometric evaluation and informed peer review yield similar results. In this paper, we draw on the experience of the panel that evaluated It alian research in Economics, Management and Statistics during the national assessment exercise (VQR) relative to the period 2004-2010. We exploit the unique opportunity of studying a sample of 590 journal articles randomly drawn from a population of 5,681 journal articles (out of nearly 12,000 journal and non-journal publications), which the panel evaluated both by bibliometric analysis and by informed peer review. In the total sample we find fair to good agreement between informed peer review and bibliometric analysis and absence of statistic al bias between the two. We then discuss the nature, implications, and limitations of this correlation.
Bibliometric Evaluation vs. Informed Peer Review: Evidence from Italy / Bertocchi, Graziella; Gambardella, Alfonso; Jappelli, Tullio; Nappi, Carmela; Peracchi, Franco. - In: RESEARCH POLICY. - ISSN 0048-7333. - STAMPA. - 44(2014), pp. 451-466.
| Data di pubblicazione: | 2014 |
| Titolo: | Bibliometric Evaluation vs. Informed Peer Review: Evidence from Italy |
| Autore/i: | Bertocchi, Graziella; Gambardella, Alfonso; Jappelli, Tullio; Nappi, Carmela; Peracchi, Franco |
| Autore/i UNIMORE: | |
| Digital Object Identifier (DOI): | http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2014.08.004 |
| Rivista: | |
| Volume: | 44 |
| Pagina iniziale: | 451 |
| Pagina finale: | 466 |
| Codice identificativo ISI: | WOS:000348964800012 |
| Codice identificativo Scopus: | 2-s2.0-84920653927 |
| Citazione: | Bibliometric Evaluation vs. Informed Peer Review: Evidence from Italy / Bertocchi, Graziella; Gambardella, Alfonso; Jappelli, Tullio; Nappi, Carmela; Peracchi, Franco. - In: RESEARCH POLICY. - ISSN 0048-7333. - STAMPA. - 44(2014), pp. 451-466. |
| Tipologia | Articolo su rivista |
File in questo prodotto:
| File | Descrizione | Tipologia | |
|---|---|---|---|
| rp2015.pdf | Articolo principale | Versione dell'editore (versione pubblicata) | Administrator Richiedi una copia |
http://hdl.handle.net/11380/1062553
I documenti presenti in Iris Unimore sono rilasciati con licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia, salvo diversa indicazione.
In caso di violazione di copyright, contattare Supporto Iris
Copyright © 2020