FSH treatment improves sperm DNA damage in men with idiopathic infertility carriers of the FSH receptor p.N680S homozygous N genotype: an interim analysis

Study question: To assess whether in men with idiopathic infertility, the sperm DNA fragmentation (sDF) improves depending on the FSH receptor (FSHR) genotype as assessed by the non-synonymous polymorphisms (SNP) rs6166 (wild type or p.N680S). Summary answer: FSH treatment improves sDF in a subgroup of idiopathic infertile men, although 40% of these men do not show any significant improve- ment. The response of sDF, a surrogate marker of sperm quality, together with the evaluation of FSHR SNP p.N680S might be useful to predict the response to FSH treatment. What is known already: FSH is fundamental for spermatogenesis and is em- pirically used to treat male idiopathic infertility. Several studies suggest that sDF could be a candidate predictor of response to FSH treatment, in terms of probability to conceive. Furthermore, it is widely accepted that the FSHR SNP p.N680S influences ovarian response in women and testicular volume in men. Study design, size, duration: Multicenter, longitudinal, prospective, open-la- bel, two-arms clinical trial. Subjects enrolled were idiopathic infertile men and received 150 IU of recombinant FSH (Gonal f®) every other day for 12 weeks and were then followed-up for further 12 weeks after FSH-withdrawal. Patients were evaluated at baseline and at the end of the two phases. Participants/materials, setting, methods: Eighty-eight men with idiopathic male infertility carrier of the homozygous FSHR p.N680S N or S genotype, FSH < 8 IU/L and sDF > 15%, were enrolled. 66 patients completed the sDF analysis. sDF was centrally evaluated by TUNEL/PI assay coupled to flow cy- tometry, resolving two different sperm populations, namely: PIbrighter and PIdimmer. Main results and the role of chance: Thirty-seven men (56%) were carriers of the p.N680S homozygous-N and 29 (44%) of the homozygous-S genotype, respectively. Total sDF (PIbrighter + PIdimmer) was significantly lower at the end of the study in patients carriers of the p.N680S-N allele than patients carri- ers of p.N680S-S allele (p = 0.008). Only in patients carriers of the p.N680S-N allele, total sDF decreased significantly from baseline to the end of the study (p = 0.021) and this decrease was entirely sustained by the sperm population containing vital sperms (i.e., PIbrighter fraction) (p = 0.008). PIdimmer frac- tion, including only non-vital sperms, was significantly higher in patients car- riers of the p.N680S-S allele than in carriers of N allele (p = 0.018). Total sDF was inversely related to total sperm number (p = 0.020) and progressive sperm motility (p = 0.014). Limitations, reason for caution: The statistical power of the results obtained so far is 86.9%, with alpha-error 0.05. This is an interim-analysis. Wider implications of the findings: The study suggests that FSH treatment induces a significant improvement of total sDF in men carriers of the p.N680S homozygous N allele. This sDF decrease awaits confirmation, since the study will be completed by June 2015. Study funding/competing interest(s): Funding by commercial/corporate company(ies) – The study was supported by unrestricted grant by Merck Serono. Trial registration number: EudraCT number 2010-020240-35. Keywords: FSH treatment, male infertility, Sperm-DNA fragmentation